NEWS
Gov. Otti Forgives Toby Chuks, Withdraws ₦50bn Defamation Suit After Public Apology as Court Strikes Out Case
Gov. Otti Forgives Toby Chuks, Withdraws ₦50bn Defamation Suit After Public Apology as Court Strikes Out Case
Abia State Governor, Dr. Alex Chioma Otti, OFR, has withdrawn his ₦50 billion defamation lawsuit against former Abia State House of Assembly aspirant and public affairs analyst, Tobias Chukwudi Egeonu, popularly known as Toby Chuks, following the defendant’s public apology and expression of remorse over a Facebook publication containing allegations of financial misconduct against the governor.
The case, marked FCT/HC/CV/66/2025, was formally struck out on Monday by the Federal Capital Territory High Court sitting in Bwari, Abuja, after Otti’s legal representative, Dr. Sonny Ajala, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), informed the court that the governor had accepted the apology and no longer wished to pursue the matter.

According to the certified true copy of the court proceedings, Ajala disclosed that the claimant had filed a Notice of Discontinuance dated April 27, 2026, following a letter of apology published by Egeonu on his Facebook page.
Channel
The governor’s counsel subsequently urged the court to strike out the suit without imposing any costs on the defendant, signalling Otti’s willingness to bring the prolonged legal dispute to an end following the apology.
Presiding over the matter, Justice A. O. Ebong granted the application and ruled: “Pursuant to the discontinuance filed on 27/4/2026, this matter is hereby struck out. No cost awarded.”
Every second brings Nigerians closer to exercising their democratic right and shaping the future of our nation.
Exercise your democratic right responsibly, peacefully and lawfully.
The notice of discontinuance, filed pursuant to Order 23 Rule 1 of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (Civil Procedure) Rules 2025, specifically identified the apology issued by Egeonu on July 28, 2025, as the reason for discontinuing the action.
In his apology, Egeonu acknowledged that his December 2024 Facebook publication titled “What Otti Cannot Destroy Does Not Exist,” contained inappropriate references that embarrassed the governor. He accepted responsibility for the publication and expressed regret over the allegations, particularly those concerning Otti’s financial management during his tenure as Group Managing Director of the defunct Diamond Bank and his stewardship of Abia State.
Egeonu, who identified himself as a public affairs analyst, also provided a personal explanation for the publication, tracing his grievances against Otti to political disappointments dating back to 2015.
He recounted that he had secured the All Progressives Grand Alliance (APGA) ticket for Umunneochi State Constituency in 2011 and obtained the party’s ticket again ahead of the 2015 general election.
However, according to his account, Otti’s subsequent entry into APGA alongside Ikedi Ezekwesiri altered the political calculations, with Ezekwesiri eventually emerging as the preferred candidate.
He further alleged that his political ambitions suffered another setback when he failed to secure the position of deputy chairman of Umunneochi Local Government Area, claiming that Otti used the Zenith Labour Party (ZLP) to frustrate his chances.
Egeonu admitted that these political disappointments contributed to the resentment that informed his controversial publication.
Explaining his grievances in the apology, he wrote: “Moreso, I would not have had any reason to write that except that I had some hard feelings over your treatment of my House of Assembly Ticket in 2015 which you ceeded to Ikedi Ezekwesiri who joined APGA with you from PDP.”
On the allegations concerning Otti’s former position at Diamond Bank, Egeonu disclosed that his claims were sourced from an online discussion on Nairaland rather than independently verified information.
“About the reference I made of your stint at Diamond Bank, it was what I copied from an online journal (Nairaland). The publication is still in their website.
“However, I hereby own it that I erred in all of it,” he stated.
He also confirmed that he had deleted the controversial publication from his Facebook page and undertaken not to make similar publications in the future.
Taking responsibility for his actions, Egeonu further wrote: “I take full responsibility for my actions and I am truly sorry for the offense and any harm caused Your Excellency as a result of the said publication.”
In response, Governor Otti accepted the apology and extended forgiveness to Egeonu, while cautioning against the publication of defamatory allegations.
The governor’s decision to withdraw the suit was also said to have followed appeals from well-meaning individuals in Abia State who intervened to facilitate an amicable resolution.
Governor Otti reportedly had no further interest in pursuing the monetary compensation that could potentially have been awarded against the defendant if the trial had continued.
The legal dispute began after the governor demanded a retraction of the publication, a public apology on Facebook and in four national newspapers, alongside ₦50 billion in damages and ₦150 million in legal costs.
Following Egeonu’s alleged failure to comply with the demand letter dated December 13, 2024, Otti proceeded with legal action to seek redress over the publication.
On February 11, 2025, Justice Ebong granted the governor’s application to serve court processes on Egeonu through Facebook and WhatsApp. The court was informed that the defendant had acknowledged receiving the demand letter through WhatsApp on December 14, 2024.
At the July 3, 2025 hearing, proceedings continued despite the absence of Egeonu and his lawyer, Nnamdi U. Mba.
Otti’s legal team presented its first witness, Arch. Uche Jude Uche, a schoolmate of the governor, who adopted his written deposition dated January 13, 2025, and tendered the disputed Facebook publication. The court admitted the publication alongside other documentary evidence as part of the proceedings.
With the withdrawal of the ₦50 billion suit and the court’s decision to strike out the case without awarding costs, the legal battle has now come to an end, following the defendant’s public admission of error, apology and the governor’s decision to forgive him.
The development also underscores the importance of responsible public communication, fact-checking and the need for individuals, particularly those engaging in public affairs commentary, to distinguish verifiable facts from unsubstantiated allegations.





